The Em vs Benzino controversy has been stirred up again by Benzino, this time in a much more thought out and intelligent manner.
Irv Gotti came by the MTV offices and spoke to us about the list recently. Although he wasn’t as adamant as Joe Budden was about the list being wrong, IG took exception to Eminem ranking in the top spot.
â€œI got a thing with Eminem,â€ Gotti said. â€œThis has nothing to do with the beef. I don’t really feel like I have beef with Eminem. This has no hatred or nothing. This is just my opinion on it. Vibe did a thing, and they had him as the #1 rapper. Shâ€“ like that kinda pisses me off. You know why? Because let’s take Eminem’s records. Watch my analogy. Eminem is a great artist, no doubt. He puts words together, he’s witty, a smart lyricist, a great lyricist. But how can we say the guy is the best rapper alive? Look at Hov. He makes real records. Every one of Eminem’s first singles is some clown shit. He’s clowning. Is that the #1? That’s not my #1 rapper, man.â€
Gotti said he also factored in the battle element in deciding that Jay-Z is better than Em. He said that back in the day, Slim Shady wouldn’t have a chance against a young Jay â€” or DMX and Ja Rule, for that matter.
â€œNo disrespect, you’re a great lyricist, but I come from a school â€” I know they â€˜battled’ in â€˜8 Mile’ â€” but I come from where they battled on the streets with guns out,â€ the head of Murder Inc. said. â€œThey would have put you under pressure. All that â€˜off the top,’ they would have put you under pressure. I been to battles with X, Jay and Ja, that was some real shit. Homie, you wouldn’t been able to survive. These niggas was going with written shit. In your grill. X [would say,] â€˜I don’t walk, I stalk, living foul.’ Saying some shit you wouldn’t been able to withstand.â€
Gotti said Em would survive in a cipher with the big dogs.
â€œYou would have been like, â€˜My name is Em and I eat M&Ms. I eat you.’ What?â€ IG laughed. He said the Detroit legend would have been greeted with three harsh words: â€ â€˜Shut the fuck up!’ It would have been a ‘shut the fuck up’ moment off the top. Dame [Dash] would have been like, â€˜Look at him. He’s crunchy! He’s wack!’ Then I look at the singles he put out. They’re all good, but they only work for him. I say take Eminem, and let him say â€˜Hard Knock Life.’ Still hot. Now let’s have Jay-Z say the â€˜We Made You’ song. They would laugh him out the fucking building. â€¦ It would be over.â€
Irv finished by saying the best rapper alive has to be Jay-Z or Lil Wayne.
Source: MTV News